Southern Jewelry News
  • Featured
    • All
    • Featured
    • Featured Retailers
    • Retailer Roundtable
    • Sponsored Content
    • Supplier Spotlight
    Ohio jeweler builds bar to observe relocation anniversary
    Pitards add Goldstein’s to a well-seasoned mix
    Golden Trove
    Golden Trove
    To Infinity & Beyond
  • Latest News
    • All
    • COVID-19
    • Furry Friends
    • Industry Awards
    • Industry Events
    • NRF
    • On The Move
    • Other News
    • Tradeshow News
    • Video
    • What's New
    The one thing you can’t do in a slowdown
    Stuller announces Bench Jeweler Workshop
    GIA releases Winter 2022 Gems & Gemology
    AGTA awards Shelly Sergent the Leon Ritzler Award
  • Podcast
  • Columnists
    The one thing you can’t do in a slowdown
    Image of Chuck Koehler
    The Retailer’s Perspective: How quickly (and slowly) things can change
    The Story Behind the Stone: Out of the Blue
    Is the customer always right?
    Successful Custom: The One Thing You Need To Do!
    Ten things you can do to raise the level of your customer service
    Is the customer always right?
    Successful Custom: Sizing up your ring mandrel
    Jewelry marketing lessons for growth in 2023
    Jeweler’s Insurance: The wrong time to ask the right questions!
  • Classifieds
  • Subscriptions
    • Newsletter Signup
    • Print Subscription
No Result
View All Result
Southern Jewelry News
  • Featured
    • All
    • Featured
    • Featured Retailers
    • Retailer Roundtable
    • Sponsored Content
    • Supplier Spotlight
    Ohio jeweler builds bar to observe relocation anniversary
    Pitards add Goldstein’s to a well-seasoned mix
    Golden Trove
    Golden Trove
    To Infinity & Beyond
  • Latest News
    • All
    • COVID-19
    • Furry Friends
    • Industry Awards
    • Industry Events
    • NRF
    • On The Move
    • Other News
    • Tradeshow News
    • Video
    • What's New
    The one thing you can’t do in a slowdown
    Stuller announces Bench Jeweler Workshop
    GIA releases Winter 2022 Gems & Gemology
    AGTA awards Shelly Sergent the Leon Ritzler Award
  • Podcast
  • Columnists
    The one thing you can’t do in a slowdown
    Image of Chuck Koehler
    The Retailer’s Perspective: How quickly (and slowly) things can change
    The Story Behind the Stone: Out of the Blue
    Is the customer always right?
    Successful Custom: The One Thing You Need To Do!
    Ten things you can do to raise the level of your customer service
    Is the customer always right?
    Successful Custom: Sizing up your ring mandrel
    Jewelry marketing lessons for growth in 2023
    Jeweler’s Insurance: The wrong time to ask the right questions!
  • Classifieds
  • Subscriptions
    • Newsletter Signup
    • Print Subscription
No Result
View All Result
Southern Jewelry News
No Result
View All Result
Home Columnists

Successful Custom: The biggest mistake the jewelry trade ever made – and how to change it!

Joel McFadden by Joel McFadden
October 19, 2022
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
Reading Time: 4 minutes

The first mall in the US opened in 1956, and by 1975 malls accounted for 33% of all retail shopping. Between 1980 and 1990 16,000 malls and shopping centers opened. This was an unprecedented period of growth for the jewelry trade.

Every mall wanted fine jewelers at the center of the mall. Jewelry outlets exploded too. I can’t even imagine the percentage of growth over those years.

Did we increase the number of stores by 10 times? Well, that also meant we had to increase the number of salespeople in the trade by the same amount. So how did we do this? We focused on selling techniques and told people that the value of the jewelry was gold and diamonds.

Simple, this ring is expensive because it’s got a diamond in it. It is expensive because it’s gold. And there it is – our biggest mistake as a trade.

Today every person who walks into your store has access to the Internet. They know what diamonds cost. They know what gold costs. What they don’t know is why those in-store prices are higher than what they are finding online.

I was recently visiting a local custom jeweler at their store. While I was there one customer in particular caught my attention. It was a college age woman who had a silver ring and the gemstones kept falling out.

The jeweler noted that it needed new prongs because the prongs on the ring were worn away. The quote was around $120 based on the Geller book. It turned out that it was a promise ring and that was the cost her boyfriend paid for the ring less than two years ago.

So, why do customers look for the cheapest price when they purchase jewelry, but then go to the most expensive-looking store to have it repaired? They don’t understand the value of craftsmanship.

Creating the same ring with the same material, but with proper craftsmanship, may cost as little as $200. What if someone had expressed to the young man wanting to buy that promise ring the simple truth? “This ring is $120 and it will last a year or two. This one is $200 and it will last 20 years. The difference is the craftsmanship.” I bet he would not have hesitated to get her the ring that would last.

Big manufacturers use offshore labor and slick manufacturing processes, like stone-in-place casting, to reduce the cost of finished jewelry, but we still have to justify the cost and value of craftsmanship. We need to educate our customers on the value of craftsmanship and stop focusing on the cost of the materials.

There was a time in our trade when a customer’s pride in ownership was based on who created their jewelry. Remember when it meant something to own a piece from Tiffany, Cartier, or Van Cleef? We need to get back to those values.

Today, when a customer is shopping for jewelry they are often price driven. However, when that piece breaks, they are usually trust-driven. Where do they go to find someone trustworthy enough to fix their sentimental treasure? They go to the long-time local jeweler. They go to where they can find the craftsmanship.

When you are selling custom jewelry, focus on the craftsmanship and the design. If you focus on the cost of materials, you will lose to the Internet’s “it’s cheaper over here” every time. But the quality of your craftsmanship -make that your strength! Help your customers understand the value of it!

Joel McFadden

Joel McFadden

Joel McFadden is the owner of Joel McFadden designs in Chapel Hill, NC. At 12-years-old his career in jewelry began learning benchwork from his grandfather at McFadden Jewelers. He developed pricing for custom jewelry and repair work for the IJO Prototype Store in Greenfield, MA, opened a business which became a million-dollar store focusing on custom, was named MJSA’s first Mentor Jeweler, was the first director of the Council of Custom Jewelers, and is the creator of the Bench Jewelers Challenge seen at tradeshows. He has a passion for teaching and sharing his expertise, is a writer for industry publications and speaker at industry events. He is available for CAD work, stone setting, and complete custom pieces for customers and the trade. Contact Joel at MentorJeweler@gmail.com, JMDJewelry.com, Facebook, YouTube or 984-212-2217.

Related Posts

The one thing you can’t do in a slowdown

February 6, 2023
Image of Chuck Koehler

The Retailer’s Perspective: How quickly (and slowly) things can change

February 1, 2023

The Story Behind the Stone: Out of the Blue

February 1, 2023
Is the customer always right?

Successful Custom: The One Thing You Need To Do!

January 30, 2023

Latest News

Columnists

The one thing you can’t do in a slowdown

February 6, 2023
Industry Events

Stuller announces Bench Jeweler Workshop

February 6, 2023
Other News

GIA releases Winter 2022 Gems & Gemology

February 6, 2023

Other News

AGTA awards Shelly Sergent the Leon Ritzler Award

Baribault Jewelers celebrates 75th anniversary

Plumb Club February podcasts focus on bringing in and educating new customers

Jewelers Mutual® Group acquires Core Luxsurance Technology

Atlanta Jewelry Show hosting GIA Gem Identification Lab Class
5-day class March 7 – 11, 2023

Kelly Waters introduces all sterling men’s collection

Southern Jewelry News

© 2022 Southern Jewelry News.

Additional Information

  • About
  • 2023 Trade Shows
  • Media Kit
  • Contact
  • Sitemap
  • Newsletter Signup

Get Social with Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Featured Articles
    • Featured
    • Featured Retailers
    • Retailer Roundtable
    • Supplier Spotlight
    • Sponsored Content
  • Latest News
    • What’s New
    • Industry Events
    • Tradeshow News
    • On The Move
    • Other News
    • Furry Friends
  • Podcast
  • Columnists
  • Classifieds
  • Subscriptions
    • Newsletter Signup
    • Print Subscription

© 2022 Southern Jewelry News.